Should You Buy Your First Home or Keep Renting?

Deciding whether to buy your first home or continue renting is one of life’s biggest financial choices. Today’s landscape offers unique factors to consider. As of June 2025, the Reserve Bank of India has trimmed its repo rate by 50 basis points to 5.50%, the largest cut in five years, aiming to spur credit growth and ease EMIs across the board. At the same time, a Reuters poll forecasts average home prices in India to climb by 6.5% this year, while urban rents may surge by 7–10%, outpacing inflation.

Understanding how these shifts affect your pocket—and weighing them against personal goals—will guide you toward the right path. This guide walks you through current market realities, financial calculations, pros and cons, and actionable steps for both buying and renting, so you can make a decision that fits your life and budget.

1. Understanding the Buy vs. Rent Decision

Every buyer‑renter dilemma boils down to three core questions:

  1. Time Horizon: How long do you plan to stay in one place?
  2. Cost Comparison: What will buying cost you—down payment, EMIs, maintenance—versus renting and investing the difference?
  3. Lifestyle & Flexibility: Do you value the stability of ownership or the mobility of renting?

By framing the decision this way, you’ll see whether your priorities align more with homeownership’s long‑term wealth creation or renting’s short‑term flexibility.

2. Market Conditions in Mid‑2025

2.1 Home Prices on the Rise

  • Price Growth: A Reuters poll of 14 experts projects Indian home prices to grow 6.5% this year and 6.0% next, driven by demand from higher‑income buyers.
  • City Variations: In Bengaluru, average property price for a 2 BHK is roughly ₹1 crore; in Mumbai, the same unit commands ₹2.4 crore or more.

2.2 Rental Trends & Yields

  • Rental Inflation: Urban rents are expected to rise 7–10%, outpacing consumer inflation of around 4.3–4.4%.
  • Gross Yields: India’s average gross rental yield stands at 4.84% (Q2 2025), down slightly from 4.98% in late 2024. Major metros like Delhi and Mumbai offer 2–3%, whereas emerging Tier‑2 cities can reach up to 8%.

3. The Cost Calculations: Buy vs. Rent

3.1 Buying Costs Breakdown

Cost ComponentEstimate (₹)
Down Payment (20%)20 lakhs on a ₹1 crore property
Stamp Duty & Registration7–10 lakhs
Home Loan EMI₹72,000/month at 8.5% p.a. over 20 yrs*
Maintenance & Property Tax₹3,000–₹5,000/month
Total Monthly Outflow~₹80,000+

*Based on an interest rate of 8.5% p.a. from banks like ICICI or HDFC.

3.2 Renting Costs Breakdown

Cost ComponentEstimate (₹)
Monthly Rent₹35,000–₹45,000
Security Deposit3–5 months’ rent (₹1.2 lakhs)
MaintenanceSometimes included
Total Monthly Outflow~₹40,000

3.3 The Breakeven Analysis

A study by 1 Finance shows the “breakeven point”—when homeownership wealth overtakes renting plus investing the difference—varies by city:

  • Bengaluru, Hyderabad, Pune: 3–8 years
  • Mumbai, Delhi NCR: > 30 years due to high prices and low yields

If you plan to stay beyond the breakeven horizon, buying often becomes financially advantageous; if not, renting plus investing the monthly savings may yield better returns.

4. Pros & Cons of Buying vs. Renting

4.1 Buying: Pros

  • Equity Building: EMIs gradually convert into home equity, an asset you own.
  • Tax Benefits: Principal repayment under Section 80C and interest deduction up to ₹2 lakhs under Section 24(b).
  • Stability & Control: Freedom to renovate, no risk of eviction.
  • Potential Appreciation: 6–7% annual price growth can boost net worth over time.

4.2 Buying: Cons

  • High Upfront Costs: 20% down payment plus stamp duty (~₹27–30 lakhs on a ₹1 crore property).
  • Illiquidity: Take 6–12 months to sell, with brokerage fees.
  • Maintenance Burden: Ongoing costs for repairs and society charges.

4.3 Renting: Pros

  • Flexibility: Easy relocation for job changes or life events.
  • Lower Upfront Cash: Security deposit vs. large down payment.
  • No Maintenance Headache: Landlord handles major repairs.

4.4 Renting: Cons

  • No Asset Building: Monthly rent is an expense, not equity.
  • Rent Hikes: Annual increases of 5–10% can outpace salary growth.
  • Limited Control: Restrictions on painting, pets, and modifications.

5. Who Should Buy Their First Home?

  1. Long‑Term Planners (5+ Years in One City): If you expect to stay put beyond the breakeven point.
  2. Stable Finances & Good Credit Score: Able to manage EMIs (≤ 40% of net income).
  3. Ready for Upfront Costs: Have savings for down payment, fees, and emergency fund.
  4. Desire Stability & Customization: Looking to personalize living space without landlord restrictions.

Example: A 30‑year‑old IT professional in Bengaluru, with ₹1 crore budget, a 20% down payment saved, and an annual increment, stands to gain from buying if they plan to stay 6+ years.

6. Who Should Keep Renting?

  1. Frequent Movers: Professionals with 1–2 year job tenures or those exploring multiple cities.
  2. High‑Cost Property Markets: In metros like Mumbai or Delhi, where breakeven may exceed 30 years.
  3. Low Down‑Payment Capacity: If saving 20% upfront strains finances.
  4. Risk Averse to Property Market: Concerned about market downturns or project delays.

Tip: Rent in a good neighborhood, invest down‑payment funds in SIPs targeting 12–15% p.a., and reevaluate in 2–3 years.

7. Hybrid & Alternative Strategies

  • Rent‑to‑Own Schemes: Pay slightly higher rent with a portion credited toward future down payment.
  • Co‑Living Spaces: Lower rent, built‑in community, often all‑bills‑included.
  • Government Support: PMAY subsidies reduce interest rates by up to 3% for eligible first‑time buyers.
  • Pre‑Lease Investment: Rent in emerging suburbs with expected appreciation, then buy when prices rise moderately.

8. Steps to Buy Your First Home

  1. Get Financia­lly Prepped:
    • Check CIBIL score (≥ 750 ideal).
    • Save 20% down payment + 2–3% for fees.
  2. Loan Shopping:
    • Compare interest rates (7.50–9.50% p.a. across banks) and processing fees.
    • Pre‑approval locks in rates for 60–90 days.
  3. Property Hunt:
    • Use trusted portals; verify builder history; visit multiple projects.
  4. Legal & Due Diligence:
    • Title search, RERA registration check, no‑dues certificates from society.
  5. Finalize & Register:
    • Sign the sale deed, pay stamp duty, register under your name.
  6. Move In & Maintain:
    • Budget for maintenance, get insurance for fire and burglary.

9. Steps to Optimize Renting

  1. Negotiate Lease Terms:
    • Cap annual increases; ask for minor repairs in landlord’s name.
  2. Short‑Term Lock‑Ins:
    • 6–12 month rent lease gives mobility with some stability.
  3. Invest the Difference:
    • Park rent‑savings (down‑payment funds) into SIPs and debt funds.
  4. Build a Rental Credit History:
    • Pay rent via UPI/cheque to establish transaction records—useful if you buy later or apply for loans.
  5. Renter’s Insurance:
    • Insure contents against theft or damage for ₹1,000–₹2,000/year.

Conclusion

There’s no one‑size‑fits‑all answer to buy vs. rent. Buying builds equity, offers tax breaks, and rewards commitment in markets with reasonable prices. Renting provides flexibility, lower upfront costs, and can be smarter in high‑price or transient scenarios.

By examining your time horizon, cash flow, and lifestyle needs—and factoring in today’s market (repo at 5.50%, home prices +6.5%, rents +7–10%)—you can make an informed choice. Wherever you land, automate your finances, track costs diligently, and revisit your decision every 2–3 years to stay aligned with changing goals and market shifts.

Source : thepumumedia.com

Leave a Reply