Investing in Gold ETFs: Pros, Cons & How to Start?

Gold has long been a refuge in turbulent markets, a store of value when equities dip and currencies wobble. But owning physical gold comes with storage headaches, security concerns, and transaction costs. Enter Gold Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs): a convenient, low-cost way to gain exposure to gold’s price movements without handling bars or coins.

1. What Are Gold ETFs?

A Gold ETF is a fund whose shares trade on a stock exchange, representing ownership in physical gold (or gold derivatives) held in secure vaults. Each ETF share typically corresponds to a fixed fraction of an ounce of gold. When you buy shares, you participate in gold price movements, and when you sell, you exit the position—just like trading any stock.

ETF providers manage the logistics—purchasing bullion, arranging audits, and ensuring that the fund’s net asset value (NAV) tracks the gold spot price closely. This model eliminates the need for investors to worry about storage, insurance, or purity checks.

2. Advantages of Gold ETFs

  1. Liquidity
     Gold ETF shares trade on exchanges during market hours, offering intraday liquidity. Unlike physical gold, you can buy or sell instantly at market prices without finding a buyer of your bars or coins.
  2. Low Cost
     Expense ratios for leading Gold ETFs can be as low as 0.18% (e.g., Goldman’s AAAU) to 0.40% (e.g., SPDR GLD) in the U.S. In India, expense ratios hover around 0.30–0.85%, lower than many gold mutual funds.
  3. No Storage or Insurance
     The fund takes care of vault storage and insurance costs, sparing investors from securing and safeguarding physical bullion.
  4. Transparency
     Holdings are published daily. You always know how much gold the ETF holds and can verify that the NAV closely matches gold spot prices, minus fees.
  5. Small Investments
     You can purchase Gold ETF shares worth as little as a few thousand rupees or dollars—far more flexible than buying a one‑gram bar.
  6. Portfolio Diversification & Hedge
     Gold often moves independently of stocks and bonds. During periods of equity weakness, gold has acted as a “safe haven”.

3. Drawbacks to Consider

  1. Expense Ratios & Tracking Error
     Although low relative to mutual funds, ETF expenses still erode returns. A 0.40% fee on GLD or 0.82% on Nippon Gold BeES (India) compounds over time and contributes to slight underperformance versus spot gold.
  2. Counterparty & Regulatory Risk
     ETFs rely on custodians and administrators. While rare, vault breaches or management errors pose risk. Regulations may also change, affecting how funds operate.
  3. Tax Implications
    • India: Gold ETF gains above one year qualify for long‑term capital gains at 20% with indexation. Short‑term gains (≤1 year) taxed at your slab rate plus surcharge and cess.
    • U.S.: Gains taxed as collectibles at up to 28% for long‑term holdings, higher than 15% for most stocks.
  4. No Income Stream
     Gold doesn’t pay dividends or interest. Your returns depend entirely on price appreciation.
  5. Volatility
     While less volatile than some stocks, gold prices can swing ±5–10% in a month, requiring emotional discipline.

4. The Indian Gold ETF Landscape

4.1 Top Gold ETFs (June 2025)

ETFAUM (₹ Cr)1‑Yr Return5‑Yr CAGRExpense RatioTracking Error
Nippon India ETF Gold BeES5,168.8837.73%14.06%0.82%0.28%
SBI Gold ETF2,644.0937.38%14.28%0.70%0.30%
Kotak Gold ETF1,984.1437.95%14.05%0.55%0.28%
HDFC Gold ETF1,906.0936.50%14.26%0.30%0.35%
ICICI Prudential Gold ETF1,905.0536.00%14.24%0.30%0.32%

Top performers over the past year across India delivered ~37–38% gains, reflecting gold’s broader rally amid global uncertainty. Expense ratios vary significantly—HDFC and ICICI Prudential funds at 0.30% offer strong value, while Nippon’s higher AUM comes with 0.82% fees.

4.2 Market Trends in India

  • Surging AUM in Gujarat: From January to April 2025, Gujarat’s Gold ETF AUM jumped 27% to ₹867.5 Cr as investors favored ETFs over jewelry amid high spot prices (₹99,500/10 g) and slowing physical demand.
  • Record Inflows: AMFI data shows net inflows of ₹37.5 bn into gold ETFs in January and ₹19.8 bn in February 2025, even as the Nifty 50 fell 0.5% YTD, underscoring gold’s role as a hedge.

5. Major U.S. Gold ETFs

ETFExpense Ratio2025 YTD5‑Yr ReturnAUM ($ bn)
SPDR Gold Shares (GLD)0.40%25.4%13.0%60.0
iShares Gold Trust (IAU)0.25%25.5%13.2%30.0
GraniteShares Gold Trust (BAR)0.175%25.5%13.3%5.0
SPDR Gold MiniShares (GLDM)0.10%24.8%12.8%15.0

  • GLD remains the largest and most liquid, with a 0.40% fee.
  • IAU cuts costs to 0.25%, appealing to cost‑conscious buy‑and‑hold investors.
  • GLDM offers the lowest fee at 0.10%, though with a slightly wider bid‑ask spread.

6. Global Trends & Market Data (2025)

  1. Gold Rally: Gold hit $2,925/oz in mid‑2025—a 42% gain over the prior year, driven by geopolitical tensions and central bank buying.
  2. Central Bank Purchases: Major central banks diversified reserves into gold after freezing foreign assets, boosting prices.
  3. Institutional Adoption: Record inflows into U.S. spot‑gold ETFs post-2024 SEC approvals reflect growing mainstream acceptance.

7. How to Begin Investing in Gold ETFs

  1. Open a Demat/Brokerage Account
     In India, use any SEBI‑registered broker (Zerodha, Upstox, ICICI Direct). In the U.S., use your regular brokerage (Schwab, TD Ameritrade, Fidelity).
  2. Fund Your Account
     Transfer money via bank transfer/UPI (India) or ACH/wire (U.S.).
  3. Select Your Gold ETF
    • India: Choose from Nippon, SBI, Kotak, HDFC, ICICI based on expense ratio, AUM, tracking error.
    • U.S.: Pick GLD for liquidity, IAU/GLDM for lower fees, or BAR for mid‑range.
  4. Place Your Order
     Use:
    • Market Order: Ensures execution but may incur slippage.
    • Limit Order: Specify the maximum price you’ll pay; ideal in volatile markets.
  5. Consider SIP/DCA
     Even for gold, dollar‑cost averaging smooths out entry points—invest a fixed amount weekly or monthly regardless of price.
  6. Monitor & Rebalance
     Check your gold allocation (e.g., 5–10% of portfolio). Rebalance annually to maintain target exposure.

8. Tax Treatment & Costs

RegionHolding PeriodTax RateOther Costs
India≤1 yearSlab rate + surcharge/cessExpense ratio, brokerage, GST
>1 year20% LTCG with indexation
U.S.≤1 yearOrdinary income ratesBrokerage commissions
>1 year28% collectible rate

Remember to factor in:

  • Exit Load: None for ETFs.
  • Bid‑Ask Spread: Often 0.02–0.10% in India; narrower for large U.S. ETFs.
  • GST on brokerage in India adds 18% to transaction fees.

9. Portfolio Strategies

  1. Core-Satellite
     Use a small gold ETF position (5–10%) as a satellite to core equity/bond holdings.
  2. Crisis Hedge
     Increase allocation during market stress or ahead of anticipated volatility.
  3. Long-Term Holding
     Treat gold as a long-term inflation hedge—hold for 5+ years for favorable LTCG treatment.
  4. Tactical Shifts
     Temporarily boost gold ETF exposure when macro indicators predict higher inflation or currency weakness.

10. Key Takeaways & Next Steps

  • Gold ETFs offer a liquid, low‑cost, and transparent way to invest in gold without physical storage hassles.
  • Compare expense ratios, AUM, tracking errors, and liquidity when selecting a fund.
  • In India, leading options include HDFC Gold ETF (0.30%), ICICI (0.30%), and Kotak (0.55%); in the U.S., consider GLDM (0.10%), IAU (0.25%), or GLD (0.40%).
  • Factor in tax implications: 20% LTCG in India, 28% collectible rate in the U.S., plus local brokerage and regulatory fees.
  • Start small with a DCA approach and rebalance regularly to maintain target gold exposure (5–10%).
  • Evidence from Gujarat’s 27% AUM surge and record ETF inflows confirm gold’s enduring appeal as a hedge in 2025.

Ready to add Gold ETFs to your portfolio? Open your brokerage account, research fund details, set up a SIP/DCA plan, and trade smartly—your portfolio diversification and inflation defense strategy just got a whole lot simpler.

Source : thepumumedia.com

Leave a Reply